The Book

Bored Gay Werewolf

Book Author / Year Published

Tony Santorella, 2023

Review Date

April 21, 2025

Fiction

Horror

Contemporary

Fantasy

LGBTQ+

Found Family

Werewolves

The Downfalls of Toxic Masculinity

Adult

Brian, an aimless slacker, works doubles at his shift job, forgets to clean his room and lays about with his friends Nik and Darby. He’s been struggling to manage his transition to adulthood almost as much as his monthly transitions to a werewolf. Really, he is not great at the whole werewolf thing, and his recent murderous slip-ups have caught the attention of Tyler, a Millennial were-mentor determined to take the mythological world by storm. Tyler has got a plan, and weirdly his self-help punditry actually encourages Brian to shape up and to stop accidently marking out guys who ghosted him on Grindr as potential monthly victims. But as Brian gets closer to Tyler’s pack, and alienated from Nik and Darby, he realises that Tyler’s expansion plans are much more nefarious than a little lupine enlightenment…

The Review

At a Glance

Overall Rating

Rating: 4 out of 5.

Would I Recommend?

Yes- especially if you enjoy a little societal commentary with your werewolves

  • Critique of the self-improvement to manosphere to right wing pipeline
  • Diverse characters
  • Slower beginning

Category Breakdown

Rating: 5 out of 5.

I am going to be honest, I did not expect the plot to be as poignant as it was. Each moment was a snapshot of Brian’s thought process at the time and how Tyler’s influence was affecting him. It started off slow (and to be honest I almost DNFed it) but after about 20%, I grew invested. The plot progression was logical and made sense, I couldn’t find any plot holes, and the overarching story was engaging and original.

Rating: 4 out of 5.

I absolutely adored Santorella’s writing in this book. Funny, irreverent, and surprisingly self aware at times, I found myself enraptured by Brian’s progression. While I wouldn’t call it poetic, it did a wonderful job setting the tone for the book and Brian’s voice and personality. The main reason I didn’t give it the writing style a full five stars was while it fit the genre and tone for the book, it wasn’t particularly unique. Still, it did make the overall reading experience enjoyable.

Rating: 4 out of 5.

Let me be clear, I loved Brian, Nik, and Darby. Even towards the end, I started warming up to Abe. Brian himself was extremely well-developed and nuanced. I genuinely enjoyed seeing him grow as a person. Nik and Darby were also relatively well-developed and I easily got a sense of their personalities within the first couple of chapters. Even the antagonists were multifaceted. My main complaint, and the reason why this category scored four stars, was that at times the characters fell a little flat. You could definitely tell each one’s main traits and at times those traits seemed to overtake the character and turn them into plot devices. Abe, Darby, and even Nik had several moments where this happened. Still, outside of those moments I could tell Santorella put a lot of thought and time into their creation.

Rating: 5 out of 5.

As an avid consumer of werewolf fiction, I was absolutely blown away by Santorella’s take on the classic and modern werewolf lore. I’ve read so many werewolf books that they have started to meld together in my mind, but Bored Gay Werewolf? I daresay this is one of the most original takes on werewolves that I’ve seen- to the point that I really want to talk with Tony Santorella if only so I can learn more about this world. (P.S. Tony Santorella if you’re reading this and are interested in doing an interview on your world building process for this book, please feel free to email me at candleoversunday@gmail.com).

Rating: 5 out of 5.

There were no noticeable mistakes.

Rating: 4 out of 5.

While I overall loved this book, I can’t deny that I was about to DNF it after the first couple of chapters. I’m glad I stuck through it though, and will gladly recommend it to anyone looking for a good werewolf book that doesn’t focus on romance or spice. I can see it gaining a cult following in certain circles, and will do everything I can to help make that happen.

In Depth Discussion (Slight Spoilers)

I stumbled across this book while scrolling through the Queer Liberation Library on Libby (anyone with a U.S. physical address can get a free library card for it by the way). I must confess, the only reasons I borrowed it was because I thought the title was funny and it was immediately available. Funny how some of my favorite books were random ones that I picked up on a whim, but boy am I glad I did.

Reading a book about werewolves as an analogue for the wellness movement to manosphere pipeline was not on my 2025 bingo card. As someone who actively avoids such movements BECAUSE of the potential for such pipelines (yes I am an easy target for cults), I found Brian’s story both intriguing and enlightening. With the ever increasing publicity surrounding the “male loneliness epidemic” and right wing ideology in the United States, analyzing how such pipelines come to be is incredibly important for unraveling them. Bored Gay Werewolf put into perspective how a man might fall into those pipelines. Immediately, we see just how rough Brian’s life is and how isolated he feels. Even though he does have friends, he chooses to push them away and continue the rhetoric that he is lonely and no one would love the real him (in this case symbolized by him being a werewolf). Once Tyler pops in talking about giving Brian personalized guidance and stating he understands exactly what Brian is going through and wants to help, it is quite easy to see how Brian would fall for his charms. To be honest, young college me would have too.

This is where Santorella’s writing style and voice comes into play. Through Brian’s internal dialogue, we can see the exactly where he is in the pipeline and how he justifies not only his, but even Tyler’s actions. It is almost scary to see how rational it all seems when put in Brian’s perspective. He found someone who knows who he is and cares for him regardless. He found someone that is willing to push him to be a better person. He found someone that chases away the loneliness. The way Santorella frames the manipulation is genius. It is never too overt nor too subtle. It hits that middle path where from the outside people like Nik can see what Tyler’s influence is doing to Brian, but Brian himself doesn’t understand just how his time with Tyler was impacting both him and his relationships. Santorella also does an amazing job depicting how Nik helps Brian see the flaws in Tyler’s thinking and showing Brian’s thought process change.

I also appreciated that Brian took accountability for how terribly he treated his friends while under Tyler’s influence. Many times in story lines that include similar redemption plots, we rarely see the characters who did the harm take accountability or recognize the severity of their actions. Darby and Nik didn’t immediately forgive Brian (rightfully so) and Brian took active steps to mend the broken bonds.

Overall, I say read this book. Even if werewolves aren’t your thing, the characters and social commentary make it a worth while read.

Leave a comment